fbpx Joe's Pizzeria | Wildwood Pizza Tour - 5 Friends, 20+ Pizzerias, 1 Night

Pizza Place Name

Joe's Pizzeria

Joe's Pizzeria in Wildwood, New Jersey

Pizzeria

Pizza Tour Review

3
Year Rank Avg Price
2024 7 2.9 / 5 $5.00
2022 6 3.0 / 5 $4.00
2021 1 4.3 / 5 $5.00
2019 2 3.8 / 5 $4.75
2018 2 4.2 / 5 $3.50
2017 8 3.4 / 5 $3.50
2016 3 4.1 / 5 $3.50
2015 3 3.3 / 5 $3.50
2014 4 3.6 / 5 $3.25
2013 6 3.8 / 5 $3.25
2012 18 2.1 / 5 $3.25
2011 12 2.4 / 5 $3.25

2021
Pizza Tour Winner

2018
Best Value Slice

Biography

Biography: 

Joe’s Pizzeria has a reputation for being largest slice on the Wildwood boardwalk — and since they opened in 2011, they haven't disappointed on that metric. But what about the taste of their slice? Expect a slice that's well-seasoned with plenty of flavorful sauce. You probably won't leave hungry. We mean that in a good way.

User Reviews of Joe's Pizzeria

Review by Lisa Riley
5
July 21, 2021
So good.
Review by Tony LaChoy
5
July 17, 2019
I am a big Mack's pizza fan but from watching your reviews I was inspired to try it. I was pleasantly surprised by how good it was. The perfect slice, maybe it is. I stay in the Crest and it is a long walk away but worth every step. If you have never had it, Joe's might become one of your favorites. It's now mine.
Review by Eric Carrion
1
September 3, 2017
Joe pizza is a rip off. I ask for a soda and was sold a cup full off ice and napkins . The old waitress with blonde hair job is to rip you off and steal your hard earn money. I was overcharged. They can get away with anything. Keep away. Rip off and thieves not family friendly at all. Rip and thieves and maybe a little racist.
Review by Cas Di
5
August 8, 2017
Just came back from Wildwood, had plenty of food on the boardwalk. The first night we decided to have pizza. We came across Joe's Pizza. We were 7, we all shared the jumbo pie...aka pizza. Half the pizza was pepperoni and the other half with spinach tomatoes cheese. We really didn't care that the pizza was overlapping the table. The taste was amazing. Our waiter Joe ( not sure that was his name ), funny cool guy. Next year when I'm back, Joe's pizza is the place I'll be . By the way, I've tried a slice of Sams pizza....never again. Just say'n. Great job guys, see you next year.
Review by Amy
4
December 17, 2016
I am a Sam's fan all the way till one day my husband convinced me to try Joe's. I was pleasantly surprised. It is very good pizza. Still a fan of Sam's but now have a second fav.

What Do You Think?

What Do You Think?

What Do You Think?

Comments

13
10 Stars - Food and service so good you'll want to put it on your "Bucket List" if you're terminally ill. Best pizza in South Jersey or Philly for that matter. Rivals Lorenzo's on South Street without all the Goth clientele. Meatballs...oh the Meatballs..... like I would expect from a 5 star resturant in an upscale neighborhood. The staff couldn't be nicer and more appreciative of their customers. The owner makes you feel like family......the family you actually get along with and like. And oh those Meatballs! Go here before or after a show at the Casba Comedy Club (Atlantic & Spicer - Showtimes 8 & 10:30) for a perfect evening.
5
Submitted by Norm (not verified) on Wed, 07/25/2012 - 20:16
So sad... We went to try it and upon ordering the large pizza there was a long black hair baked into our pizza. When we told the owner. He simply said that he couldn't control the hair situation and took a wad of money out of his pocket and he put down a $10 bill on our table towards our check instead of taking the pizza off our order. He then asked if we wanted the rest of the pizza when we said no he said he'll just box it up for his employees. Really??? He said everyone has hair and it can't be controlled. Never again.
1
Submitted by Joan schmidt (not verified) on Sun, 06/30/2013 - 01:06
The best pizza we have eaten here in wildwood....definitely better than Mack's! Their pizza with bacon and fries is amazing !
5
Submitted by Cherie (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2011 - 18:31
5 star rating - Best pizza in South Jersey and probably Philly. Rivals Lorenzo's on South Street without all the Goth clientele. Really great! The owner and staff create a nimble endearment towards their customers.
5
Submitted by Norm (not verified) on Fri, 07/27/2012 - 19:01
Everyone in my family has their own favorite boardwalk pizza and my daughter discovered Joe's about a year ago at age 11. She gets a large slice with cheese fries and can sometimes even finish the whole thing.
4
Submitted by Dave (not verified) on Fri, 04/05/2013 - 15:26
Owner is extremely rude to guests of his restaurant. Literally found a small piece of curly hair in the pizza (gee, where could THAT have come from??). The pizza was too big to fit on the plate so half of the slice hung off and sat on the table (mind you, the table that was not even cleaned). The Large soda was filled to the top and you were lucky if you could get 3 sips out of the cup. The pubescent teens that stood around in "Joe's" t-shirts and aprons acting like servers had something to be desired. At one point there was a group of about 8 of them watching the owner get loud with a patron while they smiled. This is the farthest thing from a professional establishment I think I have ever been in. Everything about this place rubbed me the wrong way. And the pizza...let's get real. Quality should always come before quantity. Except for it being big, there was nothing delicious about it. Not a nice atmosphere, not nice people, not professional and certainly not good food.
1
Submitted by Dave from PA (not verified) on Mon, 06/24/2013 - 13:24
Really, who submitted the prior comments, his family? The pie gets 2 stars because I'm impressed by the size of the slice. Thats it.
2
Submitted by jimmytatz (not verified) on Sun, 04/07/2013 - 01:02
Joe's Pizza is the best on the boardwalk! Friendly and fast service. The pizza is delish! Highly recommend!
5
Submitted by Carmela Rininsland (not verified) on Thu, 12/15/2016 - 12:31
I am a Sam's fan all the way till one day my husband convinced me to try Joe's. I was pleasantly surprised. It is very good pizza. Still a fan of Sam's but now have a second fav.
4
Submitted by Amy (not verified) on Sat, 12/17/2016 - 09:56
Just came back from Wildwood, had plenty of food on the boardwalk. The first night we decided to have pizza. We came across Joe's Pizza. We were 7, we all shared the jumbo pie...aka pizza. Half the pizza was pepperoni and the other half with spinach tomatoes cheese. We really didn't care that the pizza was overlapping the table. The taste was amazing. Our waiter Joe ( not sure that was his name ), funny cool guy. Next year when I'm back, Joe's pizza is the place I'll be . By the way, I've tried a slice of Sams pizza....never again. Just say'n. Great job guys, see you next year.
5
Submitted by Cas Di (not verified) on Tue, 08/08/2017 - 12:10

Pages